A recent judicial decision has injected fresh momentum into Tesla’s share price, with the stock approaching a new annual peak. The catalyst is the Delaware Supreme Court’s move to reinstate CEO Elon Musk’s 2018 compensation package, a development that has prompted analysts to revise their models and shifted investor focus toward upcoming delivery figures. The central question now is whether this legal victory can offset persistent operational headwinds.
Legal Clarity Fuels Market Rally
The Delaware Supreme Court’s ruling to restore Musk’s performance-based award has removed a significant overhang for the electric vehicle maker. This decision overturned a prior ruling from the Chancery Court on December 22, 2025, which had invalidated the package. Valued between $139 billion and $150 billion, the compensation plan is tied to extensive stock options. The court concluded that rescinding the award was not an appropriate remedy, as Musk had already fulfilled the agreed-upon performance milestones.
Plaintiff and Tesla shareholder Richard Tornetta was awarded a symbolic $1 in damages. The plaintiff’s legal team faced a steeper reduction, with their requested fee of $345 million being slashed to $54 million.
For the market, this resolution eliminates a major governance uncertainty, stabilizing both Musk’s influence within the company and the structure surrounding his historic pay deal—a topic of intense scrutiny in recent years. The relief is evident in the share price: Tesla closed yesterday at €415.85, just shy of its fresh 52-week high of €416.90. Year-to-date, the stock has posted a solid double-digit gain.
Diverging Analyst Views Post-Ruling
The court’s verdict triggered swift reactions from research firms, though consensus remains divided. Deutsche Bank raised its price target from $470 to $500, reaffirming its “Buy” rating. The upgrade cites the resolved governance issue and advancements in autonomous driving technology.
Similarly, RBC Capital maintains an optimistic “Outperform” rating with a $500 price target, viewing the shares as remaining on a strong trajectory.
In stark contrast, UBS holds firm on its “Sell” recommendation, valuing Tesla at just $247. The Swiss bank’s skepticism centers on operational challenges, particularly delivery volumes.
The broader analyst picture is more tempered:
* Average Rating: “Hold”
* Median Price Target: Approximately $404
This consensus sits notably below the current trading level, suggesting many market experts view the valuation as rich.
Operational Hurdles and the Q4 Delivery Test
Despite the legal win, operational risks persist. All eyes are on the fourth-quarter 2025 delivery numbers. UBS has already lowered its Q4 delivery forecast from 429,000 to 415,000 vehicles.
Should this estimate prove accurate, it would represent a year-over-year decline and a clear miss of the current Wall Street expectation for around 450,000 units. Such a shortfall would not only dampen the growth narrative but could also pressure profitability. Tesla’s gross margin recently stood at 17.01%, already well below peaks achieved during the earlier EV rally.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Tesla?
Official delivery figures, expected around January 2, 2026, will reveal whether UBS’s caution is warranted or if Tesla’s operational performance has been stronger than feared.
Insider Activity and Institutional Moves
The stock’s ascent in December coincided with notable insider transactions:
* Director Kimbal Musk sold 56,820 shares on December 9 for approximately $25.6 million.
* CFO Vaibhav Taneja disposed of 2,637 shares on December 8, worth about $1.17 million.
While such sales are not unusual for major tech executives, they naturally attract more attention when occurring near a stock price record.
Institutional activity presents a mixed picture. Sound Income Strategies LLC increased its Tesla holding by 9.7% in the third quarter. Conversely, the ARK Innovation ETF reduced its position, shifting capital to other sectors, though it maintains a strategically positive long-term view on the company’s robotaxi potential.
Autonomous Driving: The Valuation Linchpin
Tesla’s progress in self-driving technology continues to be a key pillar supporting its valuation. The company has initiated driverless testing in Austin, Texas, though recent reports indicate the fleet is smaller than initially suggested, with fewer than ten vehicles currently deployed.
Competition in the autonomous space is intensifying. Waymo faced setbacks in San Francisco when its vehicles blocked traffic during a power outage on December 20. Meanwhile, Uber and Lyft are preparing partnerships to test autonomous vehicles in London starting in 2026.
For Tesla, scaling its planned “Cybercab” fleet is critical. The market’s imagination regarding robotaxis and full autonomy substantially underpins the current valuation—a price-to-earnings ratio exceeding 320 is difficult to justify on traditional metrics alone. Furthermore, an RSI reading near 74 signals heavily overbought conditions, leaving the stock vulnerable to a pullback if growth momentum fails to meet lofty expectations.
Conclusion: Tailwinds and Forthcoming Challenges
The reinstatement of Musk’s multi-billion dollar compensation package has eliminated a key uncertainty and provided Tesla shares with renewed vigor. In the short term, the legal tailwind dominates, bolstered by select analyst upgrades and a share price hovering near record levels.
However, two immediate tests loom: the impending Q4 delivery report and the still-modest scale of the real-world robotaxi rollout. Whether Tesla can sustain its elevated valuation in the coming weeks will largely depend on the delivery numbers reported in early January and on demonstrating more tangible progress in deploying its autonomous fleet.
Ad
Tesla Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Tesla Analysis from December 23 delivers the answer:
The latest Tesla figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Tesla investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from December 23.
Tesla: Buy or sell? Read more here...
