As the year draws to a close, Tesla’s stock is experiencing a powerful rally. This surge is unfolding against a backdrop of diminishing expectations for its core automobile business, creating a stark contrast between near-term delivery concerns and long-term technological ambitions. The central question for investors is how long the company’s lofty valuation can be sustained by its current fundamentals.
The Robotaxi Catalyst
The primary driver of recent optimism is tangible progress in autonomous driving. On December 22, Tesla employees shared videos of driverless Model Y vehicles navigating Austin, Texas—notably without a safety driver in the passenger seat. Market observers interpret this detail as a significant signal that the company is advancing toward unsupervised autonomous operation.
Prominent investor Gary Black has highlighted several factors underpinning the rally. He points to the removal of safety monitors as an indication of technological maturity, references CEO Elon Musk’s ambitious year-end promises for self-driving capabilities, and notes the planned scaling of the humanoid Optimus robot starting in 2026. Black also reiterates that Tesla currently possesses “the most profitable EV business model in the world.” However, he simultaneously cautions on valuation, noting a forward price-to-earnings ratio around 220 based on long-term estimates, which contrasts with an expected EPS growth rate of approximately 35%.
A Notable Insider Move
Amidst this rally, a key Tesla bull executed a significant transaction. On December 22, Cathie Wood’s ARK Invest sold approximately 60,715 Tesla shares across three of its ETFs, realizing nearly $29.7 million. This profit-taking move coincided with the stock hitting a new intraday high of $498.83 on the same day.
Despite this reduction, Tesla remains a cornerstone holding across ARK’s funds. It constitutes 11.9% of the ARK Innovation ETF, 9.71% of the ARK Next Generation Internet ETF, and 12.5% of the ARK Autonomous Technology ETF. Wood reportedly reallocated some proceeds into crypto-related assets like Coinbase and Circle Internet Group, a shift analysts view as a rebalancing of risk and opportunity rather than a loss of faith in the Tesla narrative.
Diverging Fundamentals: Weak Deliveries vs. Strong Price Action
While the share price climbs, several analyst firms have revised their vehicle delivery estimates downward for the fourth quarter, highlighting a growing disconnect:
- Canaccord Genuity reduced its Q4 delivery forecast from 470,000 to 427,000 vehicles, even as it raised its price target from $482 to $551.
- UBS cut its projection from 429,000 to 415,000 deliveries, maintaining a sell rating and a $247 price target.
- The FactSet consensus stands at 449,000 vehicles, which would represent a 9.5% decline compared to Q4 2024.
- For the full year 2025, expectations are for 1.65 million deliveries, a drop of 7.7% from 2024.
Further pressure comes from the U.S. market. According to Cox Automotive, Tesla’s November sales in the U.S. fell to a low near levels seen four years ago. The expiration of the federal $7,500 EV tax credit under the Trump administration has impacted overall U.S. electric vehicle demand, which plummeted by over 41% in November.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Tesla?
Nevertheless, Tesla shares have gained 13.56% over the past 30 days. Trading at 411.65 euros as of yesterday, the stock sits just over 1% below its 52-week high, demonstrating the market’s focus on future potential over present challenges.
A Premium Valuation in Context
Tesla’s valuation premium becomes especially apparent in industry comparisons. With a current P/E ratio ranging between 329 and 334, it dwarfs those of traditional automakers:
- Ford: P/E 12
- General Motors: P/E 17
- Ferrari: P/E 38
The company’s market capitalization of approximately $1.6 trillion prices in a radical transformation of its revenue profile, anticipating significant future contributions from robotaxi services and the Optimus robot. ARK Invest has projected that up to 90% of Tesla’s enterprise value could originate from robotaxi operations by 2029, underscoring the extent to which investors have decoupled the stock from its pure automotive business.
Technical and Fundamental Health Check
From a chart perspective, the outlook remains constructive. The stock is trading above a key buy signal triggered from a “cup-base” pattern, with a breakout point at $474.07; the defined buy zone extends to $497.77. Its Relative Strength line has reached its highest level since January 2025, indicating outperformance against the broader market.
Since its interim low on November 14 at $382.78, the equity has appreciated roughly 28%. It is up by a solid double-digit percentage for the current year and trades well above its key moving averages. In euro terms, the price is about 8% above the 50-day average and nearly 31% above the 200-day average. However, with a 14-day Relative Strength Index (RSI) reading of 73.7, the stock is clearly in overbought territory.
This blend of momentum and earnings pressure is reflected in fundamental ratings: the Composite Score is 78 out of 99, and the Relative Strength rating is 88, while the EPS Rating is notably weaker at 46.
The Near-Term Catalyst
All eyes are now on the global delivery figures for the fourth quarter, expected in early January. Canaccord analysts note that with the stock near record levels, the market is currently paying little attention to short-term Q4 delivery numbers, despite recent estimate cuts. Looking ahead to 2026, analysts project a recovery to 1.86 million vehicles, a 12.6% increase over the current 2025 forecast. Ultimately, Tesla’s sustained valuation hinges on its ability to translate its robotaxi and Optimus promises into tangible, durable financial results.
Ad
Tesla Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Tesla Analysis from December 24 delivers the answer:
The latest Tesla figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Tesla investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from December 24.
Tesla: Buy or sell? Read more here...
